Bakunin's Barricade — Ahmet Öğüt

Bakunin’s Barricade

2015-2022

Frist version
Eindhoven 2015
a barricade inspired by Bakunin’s never realized proposal in 1849 using works from the Van Abbemuseum’s Collection: El Lissitzky, Proun P23, No. 6, 1919
Oskar Kokoschka, Augustusbrucke Dresden, 1923
Pablo Picasso, Nature morte Ã la bougie, 1945
Fernand Leger, Une Chaise, un pot de fleurs, 1951
Asger Jorn, Le monde Perdu, 1960
Ger van Elk, Adieu IV, 1974
Rene Daniels, Grammofoon, 1978
Marlene Dumas, The View, 1992

A loan contact, prepared in collaboration with a lawyer, stipulates that the barricade may be requested and deployed during extreme economic, social, political, transformative moments and social movements.
view from Van Abbemuseum.

Dutch edition courtesy of Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam

In 1849 when Prussian troops tried to defeat the socialist insurgency in Dres- den revolutionary anarchist Mikhail Bakunin suggested placing paintings from the National Museum’s collection in front of the barricades, speculating Prussian soldiers wouldn't dare destroy the works and therefore pass the barricade. Inspired by Bakunin’s never realized proposal Ogut has created a barricade using works from the Van Abbe’s collection. A document stipulates that the barricade may be requested and deployed by activists during future social uprisings.

With thanks to: Milieustraat Eindhoven, Cure Afvalbeheer

Public Statement in response to both statements by the Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam and the Collective

I first installed “Bakunin’s Barricade” in 2015 at Van Abbemuseum. It was important to demonstrate that original artworks from the museum’s collection, some with astronomical insurance value, could be included in the barricade installation. Although the contract remained unsigned and the work was not acquired, I didn’t consider it a failure. Van Abbemuseum was the first institution to agree to include original works from its collection.

Five years later, after various iterations of the work were installed in different museums, Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam became the first to sign the contract. This shifted the work from a proposal to a functional piece with real potential to be loaned back to the streets. I spent several months negotiating the contract with the Stedelijk Museum's lawyers. Grounded in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the contract ensures the work can be loaned to the public and the streets if requested during future mass protests or wartime.

But what constitutes the artwork? The installation consists of two parts, and I am the creator of one part: the elements used to construct the barricade. I demand that my part of the physical barricade/work of art should be loaned upon a request, the way it is specified in the contract. The second part includes borrowed original artworks from the collection, which belong to the museum and were made by other artists. The contract requires the museum to negotiate the loan of these works, rather than automatically declining, and must issue a public statement explaining any refusal justified in relation to their code of ethics. Unfortunately, the Stedelijk Museum did not agree to loan the original works from its collection when a group of cultural workers, artists, and activists collectively requested to loan “Bakunin's Barricade” to protect protesting students from police brutality, amid concerns about the ongoing genocide in Gaza. Instead, the museum offered reproductions, an option added by its lawyers to the contract, as I understood it meant to be for extreme situations when the museum and city are no longer safe for its collection. For example, right now in Kharkiv, the city is literally bombed everyday, making museums unsafe, the original artworks are evacuated to somewhere safe. The Stedelijk was the first Dutch museum to have a bunker, transferring many works to it for safekeeping during the Second World War. However, this situation is different, and it should have been more clearly specified in the contract to prevent the museum's current interpretation. I wish the museum had not proposed the reproduction option. If the museum chose to miss the opportunity to give original works within the concept of my work, I would have preferred the museum to at least loan my part of the barricade, as I had already given consent in the contract. Had this happened, I believe many artists with valuable artworks, including the ones who have other works in the museum collection, would have been willing to contribute their works to the barricade once it returned to the streets in solidarity. The code of ethics for every museum must represent not only the responsibility to protect cultural heritage but also accountability to the public, to remain relevant and aligned with justice. I think it is crucial that, not only individual cultural workers but also institutions must condemn the three acts of genocide with requisite intent clearly committe in Gaza, as also stated by UN Human Rights Council experts.

Ahmet Öğüt, June, 2024

*Statement by the Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam:
https://www.stedelijk.nl/en/news/statement-stedelijk-following-loan-request

*Statement by the collective (Alina Lupu. Emin Batman, Esmee Schoutens, Jeftha Pattikawa, Juha van ‘t Zelfde, Macarena Loma Yevenes, Maren Siebert, Mitchell Esajas, Pieter Paul Pothoven, Raul Balai, Rowan Stol, Sepp Eckenhaussen, Stefanie van Gemert)
https://networkcultures.org/ourcreativereset/2024/06/28/stedelijk-museum-fails-to-loan-artwork-by-ahmet-ogut-to-protect-students-in-amsterdam/

Bakunin’s Barricade in Oberlin Ohio, USA, 2022
Including works from the Allen Memorial Art Museum by David Wojnarowicz, Eva Hesse, Nisse Zetterberg, Kiki Smith, Alfredo Jaar, Barbara Kruger, Andy Warhol, John Baldessari, Raquelín Mendieta, Doris Salcedo, Horace Pippin and Sol LeWitt.

Bakunin’s Barricade in Amsterdam at the Stedelijk Museum in 2020. Artworks including Nan Goldin, Nan one month after being battered, 1984; Kazimir Malevich, Supremus nr. 50, 1915; Käthe Kollwitz, Ruht um Frieden seiner Hände, 1935; Else Berg, Twee vrouwen, 1935; PINK de Thierry, Tea-time I, 1986; Marlene Dumas, Martha – Sigmund’s Wife, 1984; Pieter Engels, Strike Project Visualization of an Inactivity Period of Pieter Engels March 1 1971-..... Pieter Engels ‘Death’, 1971; Jan Th. Kruseman, Buurtje te Brussel, date unknown; 4 out of 17 parts from Timo Demollin's work Visit (1883–2020), 2020.

Dutch edition courtesy of Stedelijk Museum Amsterdam

Bakunin’s Barricade, Kunsthal Charlottenborg version, 2017, this version included works from the Royal Art Academy's collection: Miro, Joan: Mujer en el Espejo (1956) Jorn, Asger: Uden titel/No title Vöge, Winnie: Uden titel/No title (1982) Ljungkrantz, Ulla: Uden titel/No title (1980) Willumsen, Jens Ferdinand: Uden titel/No title (1917) Nielsen, Palle: Uden titel/No title (1955) Goya, Francisco: Modo de volar /One way to fly (1815 – 1823) Goya, Francisco: Disparate pobre/Folly of poverty (1815 – 1823) Ono, Yoko, Clock Piece (1963)

Bakunin’s Barricade, Museum Ludwig, Köln, 2016
Bakunin’s Barricade in Cologne in 2016 included works from Museum Ludwig: Oskar Kokoschka, Ansicht der Stadt Köln vom Messeturm aus, 1956; Karl Schmidt-Rotluff, Frau mit Mädchen, 1933; Marie Clémentine Valadon, Frauenbildnis, 1929; Endre Tót, Franz Marc, Rinder, 2000; Andy Warhol, Portrait of Peter Ludwig, 1980; Heinrich August Hussmann, Portrait Dr. Haubrich, 1949; Hans-Jörg Mayer, Ohne Titel, 1994; Aleksej Georgievic Javlensky, Märchenprinzessin mit Fächer, 1912.

Bakunin’s Barricade, Kunstverein Dresden, 2018
The works included from the collections of Kunstverein Dresden members are by Antje Blumenstein, Markus Draper, Slawomir Elsner, Leon Golub, Edmund Kesting, Thoralf Knobloch, Joep van Liefland, Cesare Pietroiusti, Nancy Spero, and Rembrandt van Rijn.

Bakunin’s Barricade (Istanbul) 2016, this version included works from the Zeyno-Muhsin Bilge collection, bricks and other building materials, car tires, garbage containers, metal tubes, pieces of plywood, police fences, plastic tubes, scrap car, street lights, wooden stakes. Courtesy of the artist and Aslı and Ali Kerem Bilge. Including paintings by Aliye Berger, Şükriye Dikmen,Bedri Rahmi Eyüboğlu, Eren Eyüboğlu, Füreya Koral, Fikret Mualla, Wolf Vostell and Fahrelnissa Zeid.